Conclusion: Thinking Historically about Christianity and the Founding
(from John Fea’s book In God We Trust: Was America Founded as a Christian Nation?)
By this point in the book, you may be waiting for me to answer the question “Was American founded as a Christian nation?” with a definitive “yes” or “no.” You may feel as if I just took you on a roller-coaster ride, providing a lot of information but no clear answer to this question. If you feel this way, you were likely thinking about the content presented here in a political, rather than historical, way. Most human beings tend to be present-minded when confronting the past. Our natural inclination–what historian Sam Wineburg calls our “psychological condition at rest”–is to find something useful in this material, perhaps something that fits a preferred political agenda, but z full and nuanced understanding of the past may not always support our activist impulses. Historians are in the business of making smooth places rough. Education–real learning–should make us uncomfortable. The past is not always useful for building political movements. Leaps from 1776 to the present are complicated. They usually ignore change over time. Those dissatisfied with how this book is ending should remember that historical thinking, Wineburg says, is an “unnatural” way of thinking. The real value of history today is how it teaches us to think as educated citizens of a republic. (Most of the “facts” of the past are just a mouse click away.) Imagine if we approached the world with a deeper understanding of the 5 C’s of historical thinking I mentioned in the introduction to this book: complexity, contingency, causation, change over time, and context. Add to these a skill like historical empathy (learning to see the world from the point of view of others–even if they are already dead–and not superimposing our own values on people in the past who could never be expected to think the way we do), and we may learn how to understand one another better and perhaps even live alongside people with whom we profoundly disagree.
Ultimately, the real debate over Christianity and the American founding is not about “what happened” in the past or about what the founders said in short, out-of-context quotes, but about how, as citizens in a democratic society, we use the past in the present. The founders can be a source of wisdom and a guide in our attempts to understand American identity. They put forth certain principles: There should be no test oaths for office. Americans ae free to exercise religious freedom without government interference, and tax money should not be used to promote a national church. But sometimes we treat the eighteenth century–the era of the American founding–as if it were frozen in time, waiting to be thawed out in the twenty-first century so that the ideas of the founders can be applied to our own political and cultural debates. Did the founders have thoughts about prayer at high school football games? What about funding parochial schools? the short answer is no. This is why we have courts to interpret what the founders’ words mean in our contemporary society, to carefully consider historical contexts and legal precedents over time, and to thoughtfully bring it all to bear in our ever-shifting world.
To put this differently, “Was American founded as a Christian nation?” is a bad historical question. The eighteenth-century founders were not asking it in the same way we ask it today during cable news talk-show arguments, at political rallies, in churches, or from the Speaker’s bend in the House of Representatives. When we answer “yes” or “no” to such questions, we do not do justice to the complexity of the founding and thus fail to do justice to the full historical record. As a result, our present-day agendas are too often built on incomplete and half-baked views of the past. (“Cheery-pick” is not one of the 5 C’s of historical thinking.) History requires empathy–walking in the shoes of those who went before us and trying to understand them on their terms, not ours. Such a posture toward the past requires humility, resisting attempts to force the founders into our modern-day political molds. It requires understanding that the founders often disagreed among themselves and left competing legacies about the relationship between church and state. Citizens of the American republic and citizens of the kingdom of God can do better to embrace these values in their search for usable pasts. We need good history more than ever.






